Judge Tanya Chutkan ‘Could Lock Trump Up’ If He Violates Gag Order, Law Professor Warns

Source: Handout / Getty

Donald Trump is flirting with jail time if he violates a gag order that was put in place on Monday. A law professor warned about the possible consequences the former president is facing if he doesn’t abide by the terms of the gag order Judge Tanya Chutkan imposed surrounding Trump’s federal case for allegedly trying to overturn the 2020 election.

Hours after the gag order was instituted, Paul Butler, the Albert Brick Professor in Law at Georgetown University Law Center, explained on MSNBC that jail is among the points of recourse Chutkan has at her disposal.

MORE: Gag Reflex: Will Trump Really Obey Judge Chutkan’s Order Shutting Him Up?

Chutkan’s gag order came after Trump made a series of disparaging remarks that critics said were intended to intimidate prosecutors, witnesses and others who may be called to testify.

“First Amendment protections yield to the administration of justice and to the protection of witnesses,” Chutkan said in court while issuing the gag order. “His presidential candidacy does not give him carte blanche to vilify … public servants who are simply doing their job.”

Trump, of course, is known in part for his inability to bite his tongue on nearly any topic – particularly his legal woes that not only include being indicted on four felony counts for the case before Chutkan but also three other criminal indictments as he runs for president.

But if Trump cannot obey the terms of Chutkan’s gag order, he will likely find himself in an increasing amount of trouble, including possibly jail time, Butler said.

“The judge didn’t say today what she will do if Trump violates, but she did talk to the lawyers about the different remedies available to her, Butler, an MNBC legal analyst, told Joy Reid.

“So she could call Trump into her court and verbally admonish him,” Butler said as one of Chutkan’s options for dealing with the prospects of the gag order being violated.

Or, Butler continued, Chutkan could fine Trump, “making him pay lots of money for every violation.”

Chutkan could effectively place Trump on home arrest, too, Butler said.

“Judge Chutkan can also sentence him to home detention, meaning that he couldn’t leave one of his residences before and during the trial,” Butler continued.

Chutkan could also take more aggressive measures and put Trump behind bars for violating the gag order.

“Ultimately the judge could lock Trump up,” Butler added, noting that Trump has likely avoided that possibility because of his status. Butler said that “probably would have already happened to any defendant who wasn’t named Donald Trump, who went around talking about executing witnesses.”

.@LawProfButler on what Judge Chutkan could do if Trump violates gag order: “Ultimately the judge could lock Trump up, which probably would have already happened to any defendant who wasn’t named Donald Trump, who went around talking about executing witnesses.” #TheReidOut pic.twitter.com/sSWEOzvT74

— The ReidOut (@thereidout) October 17, 2023

In addition to the gag order, Chutkan ruled that the trial for that case would not be rescheduled and remains set to begin in March – just as primary elections are being held.

Trump has made no secret of his anger about being criminally indicted four times in as many months this year. He’s verbally attacked the prosecutors and judges in his cases. That includes Chutkan, a Black woman who was the target of at least one series of racist death threats before suspected white supremacist Abigail Jo Shry was arrested in August and charged with threatening to kill the federal judge.

Notably, Chutkan oversaw the sentencing of one of the defendants charged in the Jan. 6, 2021, rioting at the U.S. Capitol. In that instance, Trump called Chutkan “highly partisan” and “VERY BIASED & UNFAIR!”


RICO Defendant And Black Voices For Trump Leader Foolishly Mocks, Taunts Fani Willis: ‘Stop Chasing Clout’

Criminally Indicted Donald Trump Dog-Whistles ‘Barack Hussein Obama’ Is Still Joe Biden’s White House ‘Boss’

The post Judge Tanya Chutkan ‘Could Lock Trump Up’ If He Violates Gag Order, Law Professor Warns appeared first on NewsOne.

Help Stop Hate! Spread Love

Widely disseminated misinformation is extremely harmful and serves as a catalyst for hatred, violence and prejudice of every kind. This is counterproductive to the unification and strengthening of a nation. News outlets and journalists have a major responsibility to maintain a high degree of partiality and truthfulness that many Americans feel is not being honored. ADL, the Anti-Semitism Defense League is dedicated to offering impartial education on issues involving anti-Semitism to help Americans make informed decisions. A not-for-profit public service organization powered by Love, ADL provides free resources that educate society on anti-Semitism and ways to work together to combat the ancient hatred while promoting equality and prosperity for all people.

Free Download


Featured Articles

Breach of Contract and Conspiracy to Deprive of Civil Rights: An Evaluation of Potential Legal Claims and Criminal Charges Stemming from the Defamatory Social Lynching of Kyrie Irving

Basketball star Kyrie Irving captured the media’s attention when he faced allegations of anti-Semitism due to a social media post containing a link to the film, “Hebrews to Negroes: Wake Up Black America.” Succumbing to external pressure, Irving removed the controversial post and offered a public apology. Nonetheless, upon further examination of the circumstances, it appears that Irving might have been criminally deprived of his rights, and could potentially possess a legal claim against his former employer for violating contractual terms.

Send Us A Message

News & Opinions